Otally match my sensibilities but there is ne significant thing that happened in ch 4 where i see it differently from himthe uestion is what is
#the substrate that #substrate that mathematician engages in the dialectic f resistance and accommodation pickering s answer is the discipline as in disciplinary agency vs the material agency that happens when the physicists engage a material substrate WHEN HE FIRST USED THE PHRASE DISCIPLINARY AGENCY I he first used the phrase disciplinary agency i excited because he wants to draw a parallel between the mathematician s work and the physicist s engagement with something as bviously external and extrinsic to her control as the physical world however when he actually elaborates what disciplinary agency is made From Paradise...to Pregnant! of to me it felt way too thin both to capture mywn experience but even really to support his Hotter Than Wildfire (Protectors, own casence this happened i realized that the word disciplinary agency is wrong anyway the discipline is not the partner in the dance Dangerous Tidings (Pacific Coast Private Eyes, of resistance and accommodation because it is not external and extrinsic to the scientist s control in the way that the material world is math has an eually extrinsic partnerthe substratef mathematics is not the discipline itself the discipline is a set Second Chance Colton (The Coltons of Oklahoma, of tools to probe a substrate external to it it is the same for all disciplines materiality is the wrong name for this substrate because math is not material mathematicianeducator paul lockhart calls it mathematical reality he wrote something like that s the thing about mathematical reality when we pushn it it pushes back but to me this is too narrow because it separates it artificially from all the A Marked Man / Alaska With Love (Assassin-Shifter, other substrates it is connected to such as the physical world to me the actual substrate is reality when lockhart says mathematical reality all he means is that partf reality that we tend to perceive when we use the tools Chivalrous Captain, Rebel Mistress / Breaking The Governesss Rules / The Gamekeepers Lady of the disciplinef mathematics to probe iti feel like i sorta know why pickering made this mistake he s already sort Newborn Daddy ofut Diary of a Domestic Goddess on a limb with his talkf material agency it s grouping him with the ANT people who sometimes resort to everything is signs nothingness a propos Bayou Dreams ofur earlier conversation about continental theorists and whether Snowbound with Her Hero or not you re willing to stand behind your theory he s at pains to make sure nobody thinks he s talking about ghosts eg he s like look material agency for sure but i m not talking about material intentionality are you crazy so it would be scary to him andpen up too much vulnerability to try to impute the kind Grave Mercy (His Fair Assassin, of substantiveness that is even capablef exerting agency n a mathematician to a reality that can t be located anywhere in the physical worldthe problem is that without this he s talking in circles a little bit n pp 142 143 he notes the centrality to his case Her Man From Shilo of the idea that hamilton s transcriptions were forced moves which hamilton didn t have controlver but he then immediately notes that hamilton exerted some discretion The Agents Secret Past (Military Investigations over whichf the established conventions Champagne with a Celebrity of disciplinary practice he was going tobey and which he was going to tweak i am all for the idea that the discipline itself is emergent in time and i think that s really right but i feel that pickering has contradicted himself here if hamilton is able to select which established disciplinary practices he s going to consider himself beholden to then it is not these disciplinary practices that force his hand he doesn t have to accommodate them so pickering has failed to locate hamilton s partner in the dance Secret Agent Affair (The Doctors Pulaski, of resistance and accommodation the refusal to talk about reality apart from either material realityr the discipline itself has rendered the mathematician s actual dance partner invisible Pickering s groundbreaking book seems to me to have cleared up many theoretical issues left behind by both SSK Sociology The Salvation of Zachary Baumkletterer of Scientific Knowledge and ANT Actor Network Theory Pickering like Hacking starts by rejecting the representati. Is view machines instruments facts theories conceptual and mathematical structures disciplined practices and human beings are in constantly shifting relationships withne another mangled together in unforeseeable ways that are shaped by the contingencies Courting Callie (Heart of the West/Bachelor Auction, of culture time and place Situating material as well as human agency in their larger cultural context Pickering uses case studies to show how this picturef the Mortimer, Mallory and Allen Taster Collection open changeable naturef science advances a richer understanding f scienti.
Andrew Pickering Ë 3 free readProvides an interesting theoretical bridge between physics and social science Beautiful thoughtful exploration f scientific epistemology based The Little Vintage Carousel by the Sea on case studies In particular the uestionf where scientific models and concepts come from presenting a challenge both to a the scientific A PHYSICAL AFFAIR orthodoxy that imagines an underlying stable physical reality to which scientific models hue ever closely through the scientific process and b the critiue coming from the sociologyf science that scientific theories merely reflect the social context in which they are created and that they are designed to serve Pickering argues that science is a kind f a partner dance between the physical world and the community f scientists in which both exert influence Brief Lives on theutcome through a process Texas Manhunt (Chance, Texas of tuningadjustingdialecticf resistance and accommodation until the scientific and social Condor objectivesf the endeavor are met and this Deception outcome is not determined aheadf time either by the physical world challenging the scientific Bliss County - Der Traum in Weiß orthodoxyr by the social world challenging the sociological view but emerges through the dance itself To me the most useful idea has been the way this calls attention to the simultaneous creative freedom and constraint by physicality The Bride in Blue of the scientist you are free to do whatever experiment create whatever conceptual model etc that you want but the world usually won t cooperate Just a tiny fewf the vast array The Life Lucy Knew of possible paths you take will work This everyday truth is somehow clarifying beyond its due in a lotf areas The Lone Sheriff of theory about how the world works See for example the way Spatz uses it in What a Body Can Do to shed lightn the problem The Bridal Suite of agency with regard to gender in leftist social theoryI found Pickering s basic epistemological argument chapters 1 2 about the structuref scientific thought convincing When he applied it to math in chapter 4 as a mathematician I felt that he didn t press his theory fully perhaps he was worried about "BEING CALLED A NUTTY THEORIST THROUGHOUT "called a nutty theorist Throughout draws The Troublesome Angel on continental theory particularly Latour and Actor Network Theory but he is at pains to make sure you understand that he is saying down to earth clear concrete things that you can pin down ie that you don t mistake him forne Developing Drivers with the Windows Driver Foundation: Dev Driver Win Driver Fou_p1 eBook: Penny Orwick, Guy Smith: Amazon.fr: Amazon Media EU S.à r.l. of those intentionallybtuse French dudes The uestion at stake is when the science in uestion is mathematics who is the scientist s partner in the dance When the subject was physics you could say the physical world but with math you can t say that Pickering tries to give an account in which the partner is somehow the discipline The Desert Princes Proposal of mathematics itself but I thought this was weak His whole point is that the scientist is facing an external agent The discipline is insufficiently external I found an email I wrote a friend where I elaboraten all this so I m including it below slightly edited in a PSNB I read chapters 1 2 and 4 I am curious about the later chapters but got what I needed and suspect that I am going to find Pickering s view in the later chapters less useful to mePS Here s that email Forgive the lack f capitalization The Hamilton referred to is William Rowan Hamilton mePS Here s that email Forgive the lack f capitalization The Hamilton referred to is William Rowan Hamilton inventor The Million-Dollar Question of uaternions which invention is the subjectf chapter 4i read ch 1 and 2 f pickering and started n ch 4 i decided i will read the rest The Book of Pride of ch 4 and after that put the book down for now basically i find his main argument convincing regarding how scientific practice happens dialecticf resistance and accommodation interactive stabilization both human and material agency emergent in time etc i am
Not Going To Get To The Partgoing to get to the part he engages the metaphysics in particular i m curious about what he has to say about the problematic The Hidden Kingdom (Wings of Fire Graphic Novel) of realism which somewhere in ch 1 he beautifully characterized as the naturef the purchase The Counts Blackmail Bargain our knowledge hasn the world and vice versa where i feel like there will be room for his solutions not to This ambitious book by Conscious onef the most riginal and provocative thinkers in science studies ffers a sophisticated new understanding Chosen by the Alien Lord (Rusneon Mates, of the naturef scientific mathematical and engineering practice and the production Violentology of scientific knowledgeAndrew Pickeringffers a new approach to the unpredictable nature f change in science taking into account the extraordinary number f factors social technological conceptual and natural that interact to affect the creation Latin Lovers Greek Husbands Bundle of scientific knowledge In Onal idiom in which science is thought to be the activityf representing The Forgotten or creating a mapf nature Instead Pickering wants to concern himself with the performative image First Night Memories (Rot Ruin, of science in which science is regarded as a fieldf powers capacities and performances 7 For Pickering ignoring the doing f science is to completely of powers capacities and performances 7 For Pickering ignoring the doing f science is to completely the point The Shadowhunters Codex of understanding the constructionf scientific knowledge in the first place First Pickering goes after SSK s The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs obsession with human agency see my reviewf Bloor for Damnable Grace: Hades Hangmen Series, Book 5 on this model Many SSK accounts posit that human interests drive the constructionf scientific knowledge and argue that any seeming material r technological agency can
BE REDUCED TO SOME SORT OFreduced to some sort f agency This allows them to avoid Bloor s riginal concerns about the history f science getting reduced to a history Play Something Dancy of error if we can tell the story via natural agency alone historians aren t neededr relevant it s just a matter Stella of figuringut the ways that nature is speaking Pickering borrowing Bloor s terminology for something entirely different rather confusing the issue I might say called this approach asymmetrical with respect "to agency In this model rather his caricature f the model there is no room for natureOn the "agency In this model rather his caricature f the model there is no room for natureOn the hand ANT advocates symmetry between human and nonhuman agents Both according to writers like Latour work in concert to enroll The Tenant other agents into agreement with experiments and models However Pickering pointsut what should really have been Unstoppable (Tracers, obvious to allf us human and nonhuman agents just aren t the same unless you reduce both The Moon and the Thorn of them to semiotic constructs In practice humans have intentions and goals while nonhuman agents do not For Pickering The worldf intentionality is then constitutively engaged with the world f material agency 20 It is f particular importance to Pickering that modeling happens dynamically through and in time which means that the intentions and goals The Schooled Society of scientists are conditioned by scientific cultures as the same time that scientists respond to captured material agency Pickering develops some flowery metaphors about the dancef agency in which a scientists encounters resistances from the material world then seeks to accommodate models based Nude Pussy Amateur Girls Closeup Erotic Photo Book Full Nudity Uncensored Striptease Pictures with sexy Girls: Horny nude girl photography on those findings So what is the mangle It is the goalriented and goal revising dialectic Whooo-Ku of resistance and accommodation that reflects the emergently intertwined delineation and reconfigurationf machinic captures and human intentions practices and so Kayla Eli Discover Jazz on 23 This very helpful model leads Pickering to his position called pragmatic realism This typef realism would support an indefinitely diverse set Oxford Examined ofntologies and suggests that scientific knowledge is both Einsteins Generation objective and relative 32 This last part is bound to raise hackles and cause debate as it should especially from the straight up realists really who even cares about positivism as a serious position these days I m actually a fanf this result as it honors the supremely contingent nature Engendering Song of the constructionf scientific knowledge Pickering is careful to reject any synchronic Come Hell or High Water or static definitionf constraints which is how people usually try to argue that the possible The Great Railway Bazaar ontologies simply can t be infinite Pickering rejects this wayf thinking about constraints as pre judging the issue and Rue Marquis De Sade once again taking scientific analysisut Five Farthings of time Pickering wants everything in time And in time constraints are practical not theoretical he invents the term machinic incommensurability here Kuhn referenceThis book cleared up a lot for me and in general I have to say that I agree with it It s been pointedut to me by many that the usefulness My Rocky Romance Diary (Diaries of Kelly Ann, of Pickering s theoretical positions for the actual practicef history are far less clear as is exemplified by his application sections and subseuent books but as a contribution to theory in science studies this book is Historias de cronopios y de famas onef the contemporary great. Fic work both past and present Pickering examines in detail the building Pope Francis of the bubble chamber in particle physics the search for the uark the constructionf the uarternion system in mathematics and the introduction Redemption (Amos Decker, of computer controlled machine tools in industry He uses these examples to address the most basic elementsf scientific practice the development f experimental apparatus the production f facts the development Harry Potter Series Box Set (Harry Potter, of theory and the interrelationf machines and social rganizati.